EverWise Digital Front Door Scorecard

How Clear Is Your Church’s Digital Front Door?

Take this simple scorecard to see whether your church’s online presence is making it easier for first-time visitors to find you, trust you, and take the next step.

Most church visitors follow a predictable path: Search → Website → Watch → Visit → Connect. This scorecard helps you see where friction may be quietly costing you real people.
Start the Scorecard

Most Visitors Are Asking the Same Questions

When a new family checks out your church online, they are trying to decide whether they can trust what they are seeing, whether they can picture themselves there, and whether taking the next step feels easy.

Search Website Watch Visit Connect

Find Hidden Friction

Identify the small clarity issues that may be discouraging first-time guests before they ever show up.

See What a Visitor Sees

Evaluate your church from the perspective of someone who knows nothing about your culture yet.

Know Your Next Step

Get a practical picture of what is working well and where a few improvements could make a real difference.

EverWise Digital Front Door Scorecard

Rate each area from 1 to 5. Be honest. The goal is not perfection. The goal is clarity.

1 — Google Discoverability

Can a new person find your church quickly and get the basic information they need?

  • Does your church appear when searching “church near me”?
  • Is your Google Business Profile fully completed?
  • Are service times clearly listed on Google?
  • Are photos of the church environment visible?
1 = weak / unclear, 5 = strong / clear

2 — Website Clarity

Does your website answer the most important first-time visitor questions quickly?

  • Are service times visible within 5 seconds of visiting the site?
  • Is there a clear “Plan Your Visit” page?
  • Is the church’s mission and culture clear?
  • Are real photos used instead of stock images?
1 = weak / unclear, 5 = strong / clear

3 — Sermon Accessibility

Can someone easily watch your teaching and get a feel for what it is like to sit under your preaching?

  • Are sermons easy to find and watch?
  • Are sermons posted consistently?
  • Is video quality clear and watchable?
1 = weak / unclear, 5 = strong / clear

4 — Visitor Confidence

Does a first-time guest know what to expect before they arrive?

  • Is the children’s ministry explained clearly?
  • Are parking and arrival instructions visible?
  • Is the first-time experience described?
1 = weak / unclear, 5 = strong / clear

5 — Social Presence

Does your social presence help someone understand what your church actually feels like?

  • Does social media show real church life?
  • Are sermons clipped into short content?
  • Does the content help visitors understand the church culture?
1 = weak / unclear, 5 = strong / clear

Your Scorecard Results

0/25

Where to focus next

    Want help improving your church’s digital front door?

    A Digital Clarity Consultation is a simple, low-pressure conversation focused on helping you see your church’s digital presence more clearly. Geared to help you identify the biggest friction points, prioritize the right fixes, and make it easier for new families to move from online interest to in-person attendance.

    Schedule Your Digital Clarity Consultation

    Why This Matters

    Churches often work hard to welcome people in person, while unintentionally leaving confusion online. But for many visitors, your digital front door is the first impression. And first impressions carry weight.

    Clarity grows churches.